Monday, March 28, 2011

RE: [Electric Boats] Re: Experiences with Sail-powered Regeneration?

 

Its a tossup whether you are happy to lose a knot or 2 to drag regenerating , or motorsail , and gain a knot or 2 .”

 

It’s not really close to a tossup.  And the conditions for losing “a knot or 2” due to drag with a towed generator are pretty constrained.

 

Let’s see: Assuming the towed generator prop is optimized, it should be close to 70% efficient at its rated output.  The generator itself might also be half decent and 90% efficient or so.  More likely both of these are optimistic.  The water power required to deliver the 80watts can then be estimated as:

                Pwater = 80 / (0.9 * 0.7) = 127watts

If in reality, the efficiencies were 60% and 80%, respective, then we’d expect 167watts of water power required.

Let’s be conservative and say that it takes 200watts of water power (i.e. sensed as “drag” to the boat) to deliver 80watts of electricity.

 

Now, it’s common for our displacement craft to require doubling of the power to increase speed by 1 knot in propulsion.

With an electric boat, assuming we lose 50% battery power in delivering power to the water, then 200watts of water power equates to 400watts of battery power.  Okay, so say at 6-knots, we throw the towed generator out and it’s delivering 80watts of electricity.

We know that at most it’ll be causing 200watts of drag and that this would be equivalent to sucking 400watts of power from our batteries to make up for it.

For 200watts of drag to reduce the speed to 5-knots, we’d have had to be driving the boat with only 800watts of power at 6knots prior to towing the generator.

 

So a boat that requires more than 800watts to go 6-knots will NOT slow down anywhere close to 1 knot by towing that 80watt generator.

 

This is all rough, but as you can see, it’s not that difficult to get estimates of this if you’re careful.

To note from this analysis:

·         Generating 80watts of electricity cost the equivalent of 400watts of electricity --- a net loss of 320watts if the boat were driven by electric and not wind.  Try it and see!

·         The actual drop in speed depends on how significant 200watts of drag is to your system---e.g. my boat, at 6kts requires about 6HP.  At 5kts, it requires about 3HP---so to slow the boat down to 5kts, you’d have to add 1225watts (3HP*50%) of equivalent drag power by water or air to slow down 1kt.  200watts of drag is absolutely unnoticeable at that speed and wouldn’t slow my boat down but perhaps 0.1knot.  Worse, I’d lose 320watts additionally!

The above could be repeated to determine under what conditions a boat would slow down by 2kts.

 

In case this helps-

 

-Myles Twete, Portland, Or.

 

From: electricboats@yahoogroups.com [mailto:electricboats@yahoogroups.com] On Behalf Of Rob Johnson
Sent: Sunday, March 27, 2011 3:12 PM
To: electricboats@yahoogroups.com
Subject: Re: [Electric Boats] Re: Experiences with Sail-powered Regeneration?

 

 

I was thinking the same thing Richard.

Its a tossup whether you are happy to lose a knot or 2 to drag regenerating , or motorsail , and gain a knot or 2 .

Lots of variables , I guess.

Rob J.

 


From: Richard Mair <fullkeel2000@yahoo.ca>
To: electricboats@yahoogroups.com
Sent: Mon, 28 March, 2011 9:02:05 AM
Subject: Re: [Electric Boats] Re: Experiences with Sail-powered Regeneration?


Or the extra drag may slow you down to the point you are only getting 80w or less from both depending on the start up point..
Richard

--- On Sun, 3/27/11, Jak Mang <jak.mang@gmail.com> wrote:


From: Jak Mang <jak.mang@gmail.com>
Subject: [Electric Boats] Re: Experiences with Sail-powered Regeneration?
To: electricboats@yahoogroups.com
Received: Sunday, March 27, 2011, 12:24 PM

 

Thanks. That all make perfect sense. Given that 80W is optimal, is anybody really achieving that. Are the vendors over selling the practicality or functionality? That recharge rate will not please many owners, but it would be fine for me. Can I achieve it with a single motor or do I have to design in an auxiliary towed-type generator?

On the other hand, a secondary generator combined with the primary motor might get me above 80W?

-jak

>
> From: Eric <ewdysar@...>
> Subject: [Electric Boats] Re: Experiences with Sail-powered Regeneration?
> To: electricboats@yahoogroups.com
> Date: Saturday, March 26, 2011, 12:48 AM

>
> Jak,
>
> You already have reasonable experience with regen while sailing. If you stop and think about your towed generator, it is optimized for power generation and it produces about 80W (13.5V x 6A) at 6kts, probably considerably less at 5kts. I would not plan on doing any better than that with a system that is designed for propulsion, the regen has to be a secondary consideration.
>
> So you need to ask yourself, how much of the time do you expect your 26' boat to be able to sail at 6kts? We'll assume that your 7kW motor is driven with 48V, that means that your max power will be around 145A. If your drive is somehow as efficient as your towed generator, then your max regen will be 1.5A at 6kts. I think that this is optimistic, but we'll go with that number for now.
>
> We have no idea where on earth you sail, but let's assume that you'll be satisfied with a capacity of only 1 hour at 4kts under power or a practical range of 4nm. You'll probably need about 2kWh of usable energy to cover this distance. So how long will it take to recharge 2000Wh with an 80W charger? The answer is 25 hours of sailing at 6kts to recharge from 1 hour powering at 4kts. That assumes no other electrical load during the recharging period, house loads will make the recharging process take longer.
>
> So far we've been estimating with best case scenarios, in practice, your results will probably be somewhat less due to prop inefficiencies, drive train friction, controller losses and charging losses going into the batteries.
>
> Larger (faster) boats can do more with regen, there are a number of 40'+ catamarans that are pretty successful at collecting power at sailing speeds around 8kts and faster, but your 26' boat won't be able to do that. 8kts is hull speed for a 45' waterline length in a displacement keelboat.
>
> So I would guess that Niki was getting as much regen as the laws of physics allow for, which is nowhere near the expectations that drive manufacturers set when they say "you can recharge your batteries while you're sailing". I find electric drive manufacturers to be disingenuous when they pitch regen in small (less than 30') sailboats
>
> Therefore, I think that it is pretty safe to say that 2kWh of regen is a theoretical maximum for 24 hours of 6kt speeds, regardless of the size of the boat. In practice, the results will probably be somewhat less.
>
> I want regen as much as you do (maybe more), so please, somebody, prove me wrong.
>
> Fair winds,
> Eric
> Marina del Rey, CA
> 1964 Cheoy Lee Bermuda 30 ketch
> 5.5kW Propulsion Marine drive, 8kWh LiFePO4 batteries
>

 


 

__._,_.___
Recent Activity:
.

__,_._,___

No comments:

Post a Comment