Thank you Halden. I contemplated the same reply and had decided to wait. But in general what I've seen in my work yields the same sentiments you are expressing below. Specifically - over the last year I've moved from working with Chinese shops on SW to working with them on hardware and the collaboration is fruitful and grounded in quality.
While from previous posts we do know that Carsten has a LOT of experience on this particular topic, and deserves respect for that - I think that in the last few years an accelerating convergence of several trends has forced many Chinese manufacturers to change their approaches to quality, and it shows. Maybe not across the entire range of available goods but in many areas. This is largely due to increased pressure from a Chinese domestic market (growing faster than the export market), dramatic improvements in the Chinese domestic regulatory regime (including a government focus on rooting out fake goods and substandard manufacturing), as well as increased expectations from global partners. In some cases quality improvements have been at the cost of industrial espionage and losses to global firms as a result, but the net improvement in available quality goods is apparent regardless.
On Jun 11, 2021, at 13:03, HF via groups.io <incorridge=yahoo.com@groups.io> wrote:
Hi Carsten,
I wrote a long rant in response to your brief one:
>Remember, in these days, everything you buy, produced in China, is solely controlled by local chinese supervisors !!!
>There are virtually NO western inspectors in China to check export goods anymore, due to very hard quarantine restrictions when entering China. No one wants to go to China >now, just to sit quarantined alone in an appointed hotel room for 4 weeks.
but I'll just summarize it. This has nothing to do with China or Chinese. This is short-term thinking driving the global race to the bottom. None of us likes it, but many of us support it by purchasing products made in a factory. But lest your statement be read as saying that western quality inspectors are superior to Chinese ones, I'll just say it ain't so. They're all just doing their job, following instructions. Short-term thinking dominates industry today and this is part of what has shifted factories to China. In my travels in China, I have found Chinese people to be just as compassionate, thoughtful, kind, loving, caring, attentive, creative, passionate, intelligent, etc. as people in other places in the world. I'm very sad about the pollution and constraints on freedoms that they have to endure both at the workplace and in their personal time. Reasons for avoiding China travel vary; my main one is that I don't want to risk my freedom taken away without due process as retaliation for some action taken elsewhere with due process, against a person with connections to the government of China. Alright, it's longer than your rant, but at least it's shorter than it was! :-)
Using a salvaged EV battery for your boat motor is a great idea, in my opinion, because it doesn't generate another order at a factory that oppresses its workers, community, and environment. It also avoids causing an associated amount of mining which does approximately the same things. If I could find a suitable EV battery, I would use it. Of course, I would evaluate its capacity and ask questions about its history as part of the acquisition. Power electronics are good, efficient, and cheap these days so you will probably be able to engineer a way to match or configure your battery to provide electricity at the voltage(s) your motor needs. As for choice of chemistry: Li-ion has a larger range of discharge voltages than LiFePO4 and NiMH. As long as your electronics can accommodate this, it should work fine. Check that the battery capacity, mass, and temperature requirements fit your situation and needs. I'd love to read your report of how it works out on this forum.
Cheers,
Halden
No comments:
Post a Comment